Seqanswers Leaderboard Ad

Collapse

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Alignment/assembly programs - Patent minefield

    There are many programs to align short reads to a reference, and quite a few denovo assemblers as well. The terrific list here gives great links to many tools.

    But when I see these nifty toys and pick them up to examine them, it's clear that there's a quietly deadly dangers in many, in fact probably all, of the tools.

    Which of these tools are safe to use without fear of patent violations? From my experience in database tools, the patent mindfield is terrible. But it seems even worse in bioinformatics because the field is newer and therefore more of the basic infrastructure has been patented from the start.



    The Celera assembler for example, is covered by multiple patents and it's clearly not legal to use their methods, even for academic non-profit use. The GPL license is not what I'm talking about, but the patents underlaying its function. I'm not saying people haven't used the assember, but that their use is likely a violation even if Celera hasn't persued it yet. Celera is also far from the only patent holder.

    This applies to almost all of these tools. I doubt any one of them is free from patent restrictions. Even the awesome and elegant Bowtie is likely infringing multiple times, since about anything that uses the BWT to search on DNA sequences is patented.

    How are people protecting themselves from this issue? Have patent holders like Celera offered licenses, or indemity, at least for noncommercial users?
    How do the researchers of these algorithms defend themselves?

    How could any company even think to commercialize such tools unless they have a huge portfolio of patents of their own to play mutual-assured-destruction faceoffs with?

    I fear that the answers to these questions is that people have just ignored the issues for now and hope that none of the patent holders decides to start poking at their projects.

  • #2
    There's no doubt that this is a mine field, however the BWT based aligners could argue they're based primarily on the fm-index papers (which predate these patents) rather than the specific tweaks employed in these patents.

    A complex mess though, and one which only serves to demonstrate why software patents are generally bad for science as a whole.

    Comment


    • #3
      I think it's really the issue when the analysis tool such as BWT are necessary in the personal genome era.

      Comment


      • #4
        IANAL, but unless one has a method that is not based on published papers, a better business model may be the service model, rather than patent and protect.

        Comment

        Latest Articles

        Collapse

        • seqadmin
          Latest Developments in Precision Medicine
          by seqadmin



          Technological advances have led to drastic improvements in the field of precision medicine, enabling more personalized approaches to treatment. This article explores four leading groups that are overcoming many of the challenges of genomic profiling and precision medicine through their innovative platforms and technologies.

          Somatic Genomics
          “We have such a tremendous amount of genetic diversity that exists within each of us, and not just between us as individuals,”...
          05-24-2024, 01:16 PM
        • seqadmin
          Recent Advances in Sequencing Analysis Tools
          by seqadmin


          The sequencing world is rapidly changing due to declining costs, enhanced accuracies, and the advent of newer, cutting-edge instruments. Equally important to these developments are improvements in sequencing analysis, a process that converts vast amounts of raw data into a comprehensible and meaningful form. This complex task requires expertise and the right analysis tools. In this article, we highlight the progress and innovation in sequencing analysis by reviewing several of the...
          05-06-2024, 07:48 AM

        ad_right_rmr

        Collapse

        News

        Collapse

        Topics Statistics Last Post
        Started by seqadmin, 05-24-2024, 07:15 AM
        0 responses
        15 views
        0 likes
        Last Post seqadmin  
        Started by seqadmin, 05-23-2024, 10:28 AM
        0 responses
        18 views
        0 likes
        Last Post seqadmin  
        Started by seqadmin, 05-23-2024, 07:35 AM
        0 responses
        22 views
        0 likes
        Last Post seqadmin  
        Started by seqadmin, 05-22-2024, 02:06 PM
        0 responses
        10 views
        0 likes
        Last Post seqadmin  
        Working...
        X