Unconfigured Ad

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • benjaminversteeg
    Junior Member
    • Feb 2014
    • 3

    #1

    MegaBLAST vs NUCmer

    Hi,

    For a project I'm trying to find out which pairwise aligner is best for aligning whole (bacterial) genomes.

    Important aspects for choosing the best aligner are speed and sensitivity. In this situation NUCmer and BLAST seem both great programs for making local alignments. To find out which suits best, I've ran some tests. I found out that:
    - MegaBLAST is a bit more sensitive than NUCmer, because it finds more alignments, but also breaks off alignments more quickly.
    - At the aspect of speed NUCmer is BLASTed away with a factor of 3 to 4. Both programs are very fast though.

    My question remains, what advantages would one have when using NUCmer instead of BLAST?

    Thank you
  • Sheree Yau
    Junior Member
    • Mar 2014
    • 6

    #2
    I think you answered your own question with your tests. NUCmer is faster than MEGABLAST, but perhaps less sensitive. So depending on your project, is speed more important than accuracy?

    Another consideration might be whether you favour longer alignment lengths of lower identity, for example for detecting synteny. From my experience, I tend to prefer BLAST since the time is not limiting until LOTS comparisons and I find there's many tools out there that take BLAST outputs.

    I also like using Artemis Comparison Tool (ACT) (http://www.sanger.ac.uk/resources/software/act/) for visualising BLAST alignments. Good luck!

    Comment

    • GenoMax
      Senior Member
      • Feb 2008
      • 7142

      #3
      Do include mauve in your list of programs.

      Comment

      • Sheree Yau
        Junior Member
        • Mar 2014
        • 6

        #4
        Yes agreed! MAUVE is very nice for comparing multiple bacterial genomes.

        Comment

        • benjaminversteeg
          Junior Member
          • Feb 2014
          • 3

          #5
          Thank you for your response. Sorry for the confusion, but with the sentence about the speed I meant that MegaBLAST is much faster. I also measured Mauve by the way.

          Tested with two bacterial samples (+/- 4.2MB) with five runs. See below average durations and the sum of all coverages (can exceed 100% because some regions are aligned at multiple locations):

          - NUCmer: 15.52 s / 98.27%
          - Mauve: 82.40 s / 103.60%
          - MegaBLAST: 4.86 s / 100.91%
          - BLASTn: 33.02 s / 122.36%

          Speed is important for this project, but not crucial. The thing is though that MegaBLAST is faster, but also more sensitive.. Which makes me wonder why people nowadays still choose NUCmer instead of MegaBLAST.

          Comment

          Latest Articles

          Collapse

          • kinpict.com
            Reply to 16S/ITS Profiling vs. Shotgun Metagenomics: What Changes in Your Workflow?
            by kinpict.com
            The part about this topic feels surprisingly grounded, and the details on the page is the bit that made me slow down. I’d keep <a href="https://kinpict.com/">ai family photo generator</a> bookmarked for later.
            11-14-2026, 06:37 PM
          • SEQadmin2
            16S/ITS Profiling vs. Shotgun Metagenomics: What Changes in Your Workflow?
            by SEQadmin2





            NGS has revolutionized clinical microbiology by offering new ways to identify and surveil pathogens without prior knowledge of the target. One popular approach is 16S rRNA and ITS amplicon sequencing, which targets specific microbial markers. But studies are increasingly incorporating shotgun metagenomics, a technique that sequences all DNA from a sample without targeting specific microbial markers. This approach allows more detailed taxonomic classification,...
            10-30-2026, 06:46 AM

          ad_right_rmr

          Collapse

          News

          Collapse

          Topics Statistics Last Post
          Started by SEQadmin2, 11-12-2026, 07:59 AM
          0 responses
          29 views
          0 reactions
          Last Post SEQadmin2  
          Started by SEQadmin2, 11-05-2026, 09:25 AM
          0 responses
          36 views
          0 reactions
          Last Post SEQadmin2  
          Started by SEQadmin2, 11-03-2026, 11:54 AM
          2 responses
          60 views
          0 reactions
          Last Post kinpict.com  
          Started by SEQadmin2, 10-28-2026, 09:57 AM
          0 responses
          176 views
          0 reactions
          Last Post SEQadmin2  
          Working...