Tweet
why are geneticists so focused on alleles or genotypes as the fundamental unit of genetic variation as opposed to haplotypes? is this too philosophical of a question?
-
-
Haplotypes
As I understand it, haplotypes are a way to get a more granular picture of the genotypes of individuals. They were used out of necessity because genotyping was very expensive in the past. By gathering a single genotype on a haplotypes you could know about every other genotype on that haplotype, so in essence you could drastically reduce the necessary read resolution in order to have a deep understanding of an individual person's genotype.
Now we have the HD version of people's genetic code
(There are other statistical reasons why haplotypes are extremely useful, but I feel this was a major driver in why they became the gold standard)
-
Occam's razor would be one component: in most cases we know a single allele drives the actual phenotype. The other variants in the haplotype are neutral bystanders.
However, there are certainly many cases where we know there is really a compound allele -- multiple variants linked in cis create the phenotype. But, even then the haplotype is really too broad a unit -- the biology is being driven by a small number of the variants in the haplotype & the rest is along for the ride. Or at least the observed biology can be mostly explained by a small number.Comment
-
Well, to be frank, it's because they are. A fundamental unit of anything is the original or primary unit, and individual alleles are those fundamental units of genetic variation.Originally posted by hoffmann View Post
Haplotypes are just collections of alleles that travel together due to close genetic distance, right? Any trait that's traveling with a particular haplotype is doing so because of underlying specific variations (alleles), no? It may be more than one variation, but at the end of the day, it's still specific variations that explain why a given trait is traveling with a haplotype, and those are the things we're interested in.
In short, a haplotype is just a collection of alleles. A "collection" of something cannot be the fundamental unit precisely because it is made up of many units of something else (or, put another way, a collection of fundamental genetic variation units
).
That doesn't mean haplotypes aren't useful in a sequencing world. If we are unable to discern a meaningful variant, we may look at haplotypes as a proxy. As you probably know, this is in fact exactly what we did for many years because we were unable to survey every base in the genome. At the end of the day, however, much of the point of the haplotype was to narrow down a region we could sequence through to find the specific variant responsible for a phenotype. Haplotypes are still useful both for this purpose and for other reasons (tracing ancestry, examining consanguinity, targeted surveying rather than whole genome sequencing, and more).Mendelian Disorder: A blogshare of random useful information for general public consumption. [Blog]
Breakway: A Program to Identify Structural Variations in Genomic Data [Website] [Forum Post]
Projects: U87MG whole genome sequence [Website] [Paper]Comment
-
Data variability is still an issue in sequencing technologies despite the advances in reproducibility and accuracy of these platforms. But the problem does not originate in the sequencing itself, but in the previous steps, before the sample reaches the sequencer.
The first step is collection, followed by preservation and sample preparation for analysis. Most scientists overlook those steps, but not being careful might just be skewing the experiment’s results.
...06-02-2026, 10:05 AM -
With the launch of new single-cell sequencing platforms in 2026, the field stands at an exciting inflection point. This article surveys the most impactful advances in the field and discusses how they’re reshaping research in cancer, immunology, and beyond.
Introduction
Single-cell sequencing technologies have undergone remarkable advances over the past decade, transitioning from low-throughput experimental approaches to highly scalable platforms capable of...05-22-2026, 06:42 AM -
Studying ecosystems means dealing with complex, multi-species communities that are hard to observe at scale. This complexity, however, hides many important questions to be answered, from how biogeochemical cycles work and how climate change can affect species distribution to how conservation strategies can work best.
Genomics, particularly since the expansion of NGS, has transformed ecosystem ecology. By sequencing environmental DNA, we can now assess biodiversity without direct...05-06-2026, 09:04 AM
Comment